There was once an American president who loved tariffs, sought to negotiate the lay of the Canada-U.S. border and had a beef about the influx of illegal migrants entering from up north.
That president鈥檚 name was not Donald Trump but . And in 1891, his country cast a cloud over the Canadian vote that elected Prime Minister John A. Macdonald to , just months before his death.
It was a campaign dominated by trade policy. The ballot question: to impose retaliatory tariffs on the U.S., as the Conservative leader urged, or to seek free trade, as Liberal Wilfrid Laurier was pitching.
Macdonald warned that his opponent was opening the door to American annexation. The election, he said, would resolve 鈥渢he crisis of Canada鈥檚 fate鈥 and show Americans that 鈥渨e would fight for our existence as they would.鈥
The re-election of Macdonald鈥檚 party was summed up elegantly in a biography of the Tory leader by the late 海角社区官网Star journalist Richard Gwyn. Canadians, he wrote 鈥渧oted to go on being Canadians.鈥
And from Washington, Harrison reacted in a manner that will be frighteningly familiar to those of us who hang on Trump鈥檚 every Canada-focused utterance: 鈥淐anada,鈥 Gwyn cited him as saying, 鈥渃an offer us nothing we cannot duplicate.鈥
With this country set for an election campaign to begin on Sunday, it鈥檚 a cross-border crisis, fight and decision Canadians will be forced to confront once again, 134 years later.
The latest polls on Mark Carney, Pierre Poilievre, Jagmeet Singh and other federal party leaders, according to The Signal, the Star’s election
The latest polls on Mark Carney, Pierre Poilievre, Jagmeet Singh and other federal party leaders, according to The Signal, the Star’s election
And, once again, the whims and will of Washington loom over Canadian politics. But this time there are much greater abilities to sway or swing the outcome.
Already, we see the White House at work 鈥 all too often, in fact.
This week, talking about Canadian pre-election polling that showed a rebound for Mark Carney鈥檚 Liberal Party against Pierre Poilievre鈥檚 Conservatives.
Where an American president would, by custom, refrain from public comment, Trump instead picked his preferred winner.
鈥淭he Conservative that鈥檚 running is stupidly no friend of mine,鈥 Trump said of Poilievre.
鈥淚 think it鈥檚 easier to deal, actually, with a Liberal, and maybe they鈥檙e going to win, but I don鈥檛 care. It doesn鈥檛 matter to me at all.鈥
In these fraught political times, with every word from the White House being picked apart for strategic implications and next moves, panning the Tories and promoting the Grits throws everyone into a tail-spin.
Donald Trump’s sudden turn against Volodymyr Zelenskyy leaves Ukraine facing a trial it may not
With all the major parties lined up in opposition to Trump鈥檚 tariffs and territorial threats, the American president鈥檚 kiss can be poison, his venom something like a badge of honour.
Or perhaps, as some have suggested, Trump is aware of the revolt underway in his coveted 51st state, and dabbling in reverse psychology 鈥 a masterful, mind-messing move in a game of 鈥.鈥
Whatever he is doing, it appears to be part of a considered plan to keep Canada off balance and under America鈥檚 thumb 鈥 something that seemed unfathomable just a few short months ago.
And the Canadian government is treating it as a very real threat, as seen by the scramble to bolster diplomatic ties in Europe, find new military suppliers and forge alternate routes to new trading markets.
In the world of geopolitical studies, Trump鈥檚 America is waging what might be considered 鈥渂elow threshold鈥 attacks against Canada. These are tactics short of tanks, bullets and bombs, including the use of disinformation as well as diplomatic and economic aggression to achieve dominance, according to a .
The term is normally employed in the context of Russia and China, which have a long record of using cyberattacks, social media networks and disinformation to sow confusion among their adversaries, particularly during elections.
But it increasingly applies to the Trump administration鈥檚 approach to Canada-U.S. relations.
鈥淢y view is that the intention behind rhetorical statements, behind tariffs as a form of economic warfare, is to fundamentally undermine Canada鈥檚 sovereignty, Canada鈥檚 political stability and economic security,鈥 said , a security and intelligence expert and former member of the Prime Minister鈥檚 Advisory Council on National Security.
鈥淚n the coming federal election, I think we can expect to see some of it in terms of White House pronouncements that will be designed to deliver impact on the federal election, whether it鈥檚 from Trump, or White House officials, or from Elon Musk.
鈥淚 expect to see all of that 鈥 what you might call an influence operation.鈥
The goal, Wark said, would be to undermine Canada, extend American control 鈥渙r even to fundamentally destroy Canada as a country.鈥
Just two months into Trump鈥檚 four-year term, there鈥檚 already a troubling precedent for election interference.
SpaceX and Tesla chief Musk, who is serving as Trump鈥檚 head cost-cutter and confidante, endorsed the far-right Alternative for Germany (AfD) party in the midst of the country鈥檚 recent election. He hosted a discussion with the party leader Alice Weidel on X, his social media platform, and declared: 鈥淥nly the AfD can save Germany, end of story.鈥
The frontrunner and eventual election winner, Friedrich Merz, denounced Musk鈥檚 intervention, saying he could not 鈥渞emember a comparable case of interference in the election campaign of a friendly country in the history of the Western democracies.鈥
Unperturbed, U.S. Vice President J.D. Vance went on to meet with Weidel while attending the Munich Security Conference, where he also delivered a blistering speech critical of Europe, accusing it of having lost its democratic values.
In the address, he also raised concerns about the legitimacy of the Romanian presidential election, in which initial results were thrown out after the pro-Russian candidate, Calin Georgescu, was found to have benefitted from a shadowy social media campaign that the country鈥檚 intelligence agency said had Russia鈥檚 fingerprints.
鈥淚f your democracy can be destroyed with a few hundred thousand dollars of digital advertising from a foreign country,鈥 Vance said, 鈥渢hen it wasn鈥檛 very strong to begin with.鈥
And a few days before voters in Greenland cast their ballots in an election dominated by the question of independence from Denmark and the threat of annexation by the United States, Trump struck a conciliatory tone to residents of the strategically placed Arctic island.
鈥淲e strongly support your right to determine your own future,鈥 he said in , adding: 鈥淏ut we need to get (Greenland), really, for international world security, and I think we鈥檙e going to get it. One way or the other, we鈥檙e going to get it.鈥
The election of Mark Carney as Liberal Party leader may have given the White House some pause, or at least reason to recalibrate their approach to any planned Canadian interventions, said Michael Williams, a University of Ottawa professor and expert in right-wing political movements.
鈥淲here they tend to have somebody they would like to do well or to win they tend to be fairly overt about it,鈥 he said. 鈥淲hat I find really interesting is they don鈥檛 actually seem to find that person in Canada.鈥
Trump, who Williams described as 鈥渁 personalist politician鈥 鈥 one who revels in branding opponents with humiliating nicknames and personal insults 鈥 鈥渉as been quite quiet on Carney,鈥 he noted.
鈥淢y guess is that they鈥檒l see where the numbers are on that and then try and decide exactly how they will come at it. It seems to me that Trump goes with his gut on a lot of this stuff. You never really know which way it鈥檚 going to come out until it comes out.鈥
Another possibility is that Washington is retooling its Canada strategy after seeing their northern neighbours coalesce rather than crumble in the face of tariffs and sovereignty threats. Trump has certainly taken note of Ontario Premier Doug Ford鈥檚 recent election win after campaigning that he was the best leader to stand up to America鈥檚 threats.聽
Threatening to slap a tax on U.S.-bound hydroelectricity, or cut it off altogether, earned Ford what might be Trump鈥檚 highest praise. He referred to the Ontario leader as 鈥.鈥 (When he backed down amid the lure of negotiations, Trump boasted that Ford has withdrawn his 鈥渓ittle threat,鈥 while Trump鈥檚 Commerce Secretary, Howard Lutnick, dismissed the Ontario premier as 鈥渟ome guy in Ontario.鈥)
Trump鈥檚 trade battle with allies has been called 鈥渢he dumbest in history.鈥 For Lutnick, the job
Wark noted that for foreign influence operations to have impact, 鈥渢here has to be a receptive audience, and there has to be a kind of pre-existing narrative that it can play to and amplify and boost.鈥
In the target countries or regions, disinformation or misinformation campaigns have amplified angry sentiments about migration, demonized Ukraine, inflated crime statistics and 鈥 that lingering grievance 鈥 stoked anger about vaccine mandates and public health restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic.
In the German election, the AfD greatly increased its vote share and finished a strong second place. In Greenland as well, the party that was most open to having deeper economic ties to the U.S., the pro-independence Naleraq, won eight seats in Greenland鈥檚 31-seat Inatsisartut, or Parliament.
With the exception of a fringe Make Canada Great Again movement that shares Trump鈥檚 priorities 鈥 tackling immigration, crime, government spending and woke ideology 鈥 Canadians have shown few signs of clamouring for American statehood, Williams said.
鈥淐anada 鈥 a country that really has not had a strong or serious sense of itself for quite a long time now 鈥 is all of a sudden becoming quite focused in quite a different way, I think.鈥